Mature ornamental pear trees beside a tidy sidewalk in a quiet Southern California hillside neighborhood, with pale stucco homes beyond.

Diamond Bar Inherited Its Bradford Pears. A Court Case Decided When They Go.

Along Montefino Avenue, Longview Drive and parts of Diamond Bar Boulevard, many of the street trees in front of homes are Bradford pears, a species once widely planted for its fast growth and showy white blossoms. This winter, about 246 of them are scheduled to come down.

Developers planted most of these trees before Diamond Bar became a city, and the city took them on when it incorporated. They're coming out in a single winter project because a lawsuit over one branch on Montefino Avenue made the city answerable for how the species behaves as it ages.

Planted Before There Was a City to Plant Them

The November 3 agenda report presented to the City Council explains the history. Most of the Bradford pears were planted by developers before Diamond Bar incorporated in 1989. At that time the tree was on Los Angeles County's approved planting list. The builders of these tracts chose from what the county allowed, and the city took over those trees when it formed, along with the streets they shade.

The same report puts the expected lifespan of a Bradford pear at about 25 years. The trees have passed that mark or are close to it. Diamond Bar looks after more than 11,200 city-owned trees in parkways, medians and other public spaces, so the pears make up only about 2 percent of its urban forest. That's a small share of the total, but these trees are concentrated in front of homes. According to the report, many of them stand in parkways directly in front of or next to residential properties.

The Shape That Made Them Popular Is the Problem

Bradford pears were once considered ideal street trees, the city's project announcement says. The same announcement adds that the species has a weak branch structure, so mature trees tend to split and break, especially in wind.

Horticulturists outside California describe the same pattern. The University of Maryland Extension says the tree's narrow-angle trunk connections make it prone to storm breakage. NC State Extension lists weak branch unions and brittle wood as structural flaws. It says the trees can break under their own weight and in mild or moderate storms.

The city's announcement ties the risk to maturity, and the pears planted before 1989 have now reached it.

One Branch on Montefino Avenue

The case started in July 2018, when a limb about eight inches thick fell from a city-owned Bradford pear on Montefino Avenue and injured a pedestrian. The lawsuit was filed in 2019 and reached a jury trial in March 2024.

The trial record made this a citywide issue. The Court of Appeal's opinion recounts two earlier branch failures from the same tree. It also recounts nine more failures from other Bradford pears in the neighborhood over the preceding five years. The jury returned a $750,000 verdict, and on March 11, 2026, the appellate court affirmed it. According to the Metropolitan News-Enterprise, the court ruled that the earlier branch failures nearby could be considered as evidence that the city had notice.

The city's agenda report names the ruling as the reason for the project:

"To address the characteristic deficiencies of mature BPTs and the finding by the court that the City had notice of dangerous conditions caused by the BPTs, staff has developed a proactive Bradford Pear Tree Removal and Replacement Project for the City Council's approval."

The appellate decision came on March 11, and the council approved the removal on November 3, a gap of just under eight months. Under the ruling, failures from other trees of the same species could show the city had notice. That changed how risky it was to leave the remaining pears standing, and it explains why the city is removing every Bradford pear in one coordinated project instead of waiting for individual trees to decline.

What $350,000 Buys

To pay for the project, the agenda report recommended a $350,000 appropriation from the General Fund reserve and a matching increase to the city's existing agreement with its tree contractor, West Coast Arborists, Inc.

Phase Budget What it covers Expected timing
Phase One: removal $250,000 Removing about 246 Bradford pears from city right-of-way and city property, one area at a time Starting as early as mid-November, six to eight weeks depending on weather
Phase Two: replacement $100,000 City-funded replacement trees at eligible locations, on request Spring 2027

Removal works out to roughly $1,000 per tree. The report says city staff confirmed with West Coast Arborists that the $350,000 is enough for both phases.

How the Work Arrives on Your Street

The pears aren't all in one place. The city's announcement says they're concentrated around Montefino Avenue, Longview Drive and Diamond Bar Boulevard, while the agenda report says they're spread throughout the city. Crews will work through one geographic area at a time so that no neighborhood has to deal with all of it at once.

If a pear stands in front of your home, notice comes in this order:

  1. A letter from the city. Staff planned to mail these immediately after the November 3 approval.
  2. Signs posted in and around the work areas.
  3. A door hanger shortly before crews arrive, listing temporary traffic, parking and pedestrian changes for that block.

The city scheduled a community presentation for Saturday, November 14, in the Windmill Room at City Hall, 21810 Copley Drive. Diamond Bar-Walnut Patch covered the approval and the notification plan the day after the council vote.

Weather may change the timing. The agenda report notes that forecasters expect a strong El Niño this winter and says removals may be postponed during bad weather. The six-to-eight-week estimate is subject to those conditions.

A Replacement Tree Is Something You Request

Each affected household makes a choice in Phase Two. Removing the trees is automatic, and replacing them is not. New trees will be planted on request, at no cost to property owners, wherever a site assessment finds room for one. The agenda report says a replacement may not be suitable at every location, and the city will tell residents when that's the case.

Where planting works, residents near each site choose from a list of trees suited to the local climate and parkway conditions. The city plans to plant in spring 2027, when conditions are best, and has said it will share more replacement details with the community closer to then.

Developers chose the trees that now line Montefino Avenue and Longview Drive. For the replacements, residents who request one will pick from the city's list.

For updates, the city keeps a Bradford Pear Tree Removal and Replacement Project page. Public Works can be reached at 909-839-7060 or [email protected].

A change to the trees in front of a home is something buyers notice right away, and something we notice with every client too. At Christine Kennedy, we follow these neighborhood projects because they affect how your street looks and how your home shows. If you're curious how your Diamond Bar home compares after the pears come down, or once a new parkway tree goes in next spring, we'd be glad to put together a free home valuation for you.

Work With Us

Whether their clients are looking to buy or sell their home, the Kennedys + Associates strive to make their experience as stress-free and seamless as possible. Don’t navigate the complicated market alone, turn to the Kennedys + Associates to help turn your real estate dreams into reality.

Follow Me on Instagram